An Analysis of Cross-Continental Scholarship Requirements During Neurosurgical Training and National Research Productivity
Journal – journal of neurosurgery
Publication date – Mar – 2020
Authors – Michael S Rallo, Omar Ashraf, Fareed Jumah, Gaurav Gupta, Anil Nanda
Keywords – neurosurgical trainee research; global neurosurgery; neurosurgery education
Open access – Yes
Speciality – Neurosurgery, Surgical Education
World region Global
Language – English
Submitted to the One Surgery Index on May 31, 2020 at 2:32 pm
Objective: Engagement in research and scholarship is considered a hallmark of neurosurgical training. However, the participation of neurosurgical trainees in this experience has only recently been analyzed and described in the United States, with little, if any, data available regarding the research environment in neurosurgical training programs across the globe. Here, the authors set out to identify requirements for research involvement and to quantify publication rates in leading neurosurgical journals throughout various nations across the globe.
Methods: The first aim was to identify the research requirements set by relevant program-accrediting and/or board-certifying agencies via query of the literature and published guidelines. For the second part of the study, the authors attempted to determine each country’s neurosurgical research productivity by quantifying publications in the various large international neurosurgical journals-World Neurosurgery, Journal of Neurosurgery, and Neurosurgery-via a structured search of PubMed.
Results: Data on neurosurgical training requirements addressing research were available for 54 (28.1%) of 192 countries. Specific research requirements were identified for 39 countries, partial requirements for 8, and no requirements for 7. Surprisingly, the authors observed a trend of increased average research productivity with the absence of designated research requirements, although this finding is not unprecedented in the literature.
Conclusions: A variety of countries of various sizes and neurosurgical workforce densities across the globe have instituted research requirements during training and/or prior to board certification in neurosurgery. These requirements range in intensity from 1 publication or presentation to the completion of a thesis or dissertation and occur at various time points throughout training. While these requirements do not correlate directly to national research productivity, they may provide a foundation for developing countries to establish a culture of excellence in research.
OSI Number – 20460
PMID – 32114557